Home  >  Reads for Women  >  Girl Talk

Fool Me Once Shame On You – Don’t Get Fooled Again

fool me once shame on you

We can all fall in love with the wrong guy. Serial heartbreakers can fool you once. But if you let him back in and get fooled twice, shame on you.

We all know the guy who makes us throw all common sense out the window. We know they’re so, so bad for us, but we don’t care. Being guided by chemistry and pleasure, whatever pain they cause can’t touch the way they make us feel. The problem is that if it didn’t work the first time and they didn’t treat you well enough to keep you, history is likely to repeat itself.

Just because he is showing up on your doorstep begging for your forgiveness and saying that he can’t live without you, or that you are the only one for him, that doesn’t mean that he isn’t the same guy who broke your heart in the past.

Serial heartbreakers don’t typically change. Fool me once, fine. Everyone can fall in love with that type of personality once, throwing caution to the wind, thinking that they are somehow different. But if the signs are there twice, then don’t fall for it again.

In most relationships that end badly and someone really gets hurt, they surely had forewarnings along the way, if not right from the get-go. The key is to wake up and see the signs, even if you don’t want to. [Read: Is he interested in you for all the wrong reasons?]

9 questions to ask yourself to see if you were fooled once and will be fooled again

Whatever it is about him that drives you wild is not worth being belittled, cheated on, or just plain treated insignificantly. Before you believe him that his tears are real, look at this checklist of 9 questions to help you determine if he’s likely to fool you again and again.

#1 What did you think when you met him? When you met him, did you think that you were the luckiest woman in the entire world? Guys who are self-involved and make you feel like they are doing you a favor are likely narcissists, and as anyone knows, narcissists not only do not change, but they are also never going to give you what you need to be whole, happy and secure in your relationship.

If you’ve always felt that he was better than you, then it will probably never work. Idolization is different from love, and it is important to know the difference. [Read: 10 signs you’re dating a self-obsessed narcissist!]

#2 Did you catch him lying? The key to any successful relationship is trust and honesty. If he looked you right in the eye over and again and lied to you, then you would be a fool to engage in a relationship with him again. You can’t have a healthy relationship with someone who isn’t honest. It will always leave you wondering whether or not he is telling the truth, and that is a very difficult thing to live with. Being honest with the person you love is key to a happy union. [Read: The easiest ways to catch a lying boyfriend]

#3 Did he cheat on you? Okay, I know this is going to cause some controversy, but in my experience, once a cheat, always a cheat. There are likely going to be all sorts of reasons that he will give you for why he went astray, but they will most likely all revolve around what you didn’t do for him, or how he felt. There is hardly ever any discussion about how you felt when he cheated.

The guy who cheats is likely someone who will put his own needs ahead of yours. The next time there is something amiss in the relationship, he will probably do it again. Unfortunately, a leopard doesn’t change his spots. If he cheated once and broke your heart, he has the human capacity to do it again. There is a difference in character between those who make a commitment and keep it and those who don’t. [Read: 16 subtle signs he’s definitely cheating on you!]

#4 Did he go out with someone immediately after you? If he went out with someone immediately after he broke your heart, then he really didn’t take much time to grieve your loss. He will likely tell you that he tried being with someone, but it just didn’t work. What that really translates into is, “I can’t be on my own.” It didn’t work with you, so he bounced into someone else’s arms.

When it doesn’t work with you again, he will likely bounce again. That isn’t to say that someone can’t make a mistake and want you back, but if they were able to hop into bed with someone else the next night, then that is behavior that you really have to think twice about. A guy who isn’t fazed by losing love upfront is likely to fool you again.

#5 How do your friends talk about him now that he is gone? Have you ever noticed that your closest friends and family members typically wait until he is gone to say things like, “I always hated that guy.” If you find that those who love you most have always felt that there was something not right about your boyfriend, they didn’t like him, or they didn’t like the way he treated you, then it’s best to move along.

He may have fooled you, but he certainly wasn’t fooling others in your life who didn’t have stars in their eyes. Don’t be fooled again—see him through your other loved ones’ eyes. [Read: 13 signs your friends are ruining your relationship]

#6 How quickly did he change his Facebook status? If he wasn’t out the door for more than two seconds before you were history and he was uploading his new status on Facebook, then he didn’t really care about you as much as you thought. If he wasn’t fazed by your broken heart and felt that two minutes was an appropriate length of time to announce his new freedom, then he was on the lurch before he made the status change. It’s all right to get back on the horse, but at least wait until the first body is dead. [Read: How Facebook ruins relationships: 15 things to remember]

#7 Did you lose a whole bunch of weight? If you two broke up and immediately afterwards, you lost a whole lot of weight, then that may be a sign that you were losing physical attraction for your mate, or that you just didn’t care that much about keeping him to begin with. Gaining weight is usually a sign of depression or a lack of caring for the way you look. When someone is good for you and challenges you to be your best, you want to be your best, not break out the sweat pants and pile on the poundage.

Your weight is a good measure of your happiness in a relationship. If you find that you lost weight without even trying, it may be due to stress and grief, or it may be that you secretly weren’t as in love as you thought. Maybe there was something that you were negating in your own feelings. Just because he wants you back does not mean that you want him back. You may have been fooling yourself into thinking that it was something that it wasn’t all along. [Read: 12 signs that you’re starting to fall out of love]

#8 Do you find yourself smiling more and feeling happier? There are always going to be times when someone leaves and you are going to miss them and feel low. But if after the initial shock and despair wears off, you suddenly find that a weight has lifted, then he may not have been the one fooling you—you may have been fooling yourself.

You are always going to move on and find a new normal, but if you notice right away that you feel better, less stressed, or less lonely, then it may be that you didn’t really love him the way that you thought. He may have done you a favor by cutting you loose. [Read: 10 reasons why you feel relieved after breaking up]

#9 Did the comeback kid come back after seeing you with someone else? If he broke up with you for no real reason, but then after seeing you with someone else, he all of a sudden has to have you back, that is a red flag that you are likely going to get fooled again.

The type of guy who gives no reason for breaking it off but comes back the minute you find someone else is someone who wants what he can’t have and doesn’t want what he does have. Don’t invest your time in someone who only wants you as a notch in his bedpost or display on his arm. He fooled you into believing you were his number-one to get you to fall in love, and then once there, he didn’t want you anymore. Sound familiar?

There are all sorts of ways that we can be fooled by those we love, as well as ourselves. If you have a guy on your porch begging to have you back, it’s important to examine the details of your relationship as objectively as you can. [Read: 12 subtle signs you’re being manipulated by your lover]

When someone ends a relationship and hurts you, you are likely to remember only what you miss, and negate the things you don’t. It’s okay that you took a leap of faith the first time around. But this time, however, make sure that you look before you leap to protect yourself from getting fooled again.

Liked what you just read? Like us on Facebook Twitter Pinterest and we promise, we’ll be your lucky charm to a beautiful love life.

Julie Keating
Julie Keating

A writer isn’t born, but created out of experiences. No lack of subject matter, my life reads more like fiction than anything that could have been imagined...

Follow Julie on

Don't Miss this!

Latest in LovePanky


One thought on “Fool Me Once Shame On You – Don’t Get Fooled Again”

  1. Riz says:

    I’ve been dating Nick for a little over two months. He knows I want him to be my boyfriend, he is hesitant because he’s focusing on his career/he’s rushed into relationships in the past only to end up in something toxic. I’ve expressed concern about him sleeping with other people because I don’t want to get any STDs and his response has always been “You have nothing to worry about” and I haven’t been able to get a straight yes/no if we’re exclusive. I haven’t dated anyone else and Nick and I stay at each other’s houses 4 nights a week. He works the nights we don’t see each other. Overall, things have been great and we are very affectionate. Anyway! Last night we made plans for me to sleep there because we had a special event that we got tickets for very early this morning. This event sold out months ago and I got a ticket before I met him. He told me this week he wanted to go and I jumped through hoops working with the org to get him a ticket despite a full waitlist. They agreed. I texted him last night at 11 and told him I could head over at any time. He is a 15 min uber ride away. He texted me back at 1:30am and said I should come over (right when the surge charges are the worst!). We texted throughout my ride and he called me at 2:09 but I didn’t answer because I was talking to my driver, but I texted him at 2:12 that I was almost there and I arrived at 2:14. I texted and called him multiple times and rang his doorbell repeatedly. He never answered. I waited for 20 minutes before I went back home. I didn’t hear from him until 9AM when the event was just starting when he called me to ask what I was doing. He forgot that the event started at that time. He showed up at the venue an hour later and apologized. He said he got drunk with his roommate who was upset and he passed out. He said it was an accident and he would never do this on purpose. He slipped in calling me his girlfriend while referencing everything he was doing to get there to show me he was sorry (getting up, renting a car, convincing them to let him in despite not having his ticket and the event already being over). I told him that he needs to do more than just apologize and he needs to make changes. He said he would cut back on drinking and smoking. He also did this in December when we had plans to meet up after our nights out. I was at a bar and got harassed by a man over and over for many hours and I had to get physical with him to get him away from me. I only weigh 107 pounds so I couldn’t do much, and this was all self defense but I was able to knock the man onto the ground and get away. I was still incredibly shaken and terrified. I texted Nick and told him what happened and that I needed to leave and he told me to go to his house and he was heading there. I waited a few minutes before I left to give him time but when I arrived I had to wait 30 minutes before he arrived. He didn’t leave his party until after I was already at his house. His excuse was he was playing beer pong and “just couldn’t lose.” I didn’t get angry because I was still in bad shape from my confrontation with the man at the bar. Nick doesn’t live in the best area and both of these nights it was below freezing. Earlier this week we also had plans to go out but when I was about to leave he never responded and called me at 5am saying he fell asleep. I asked him to never do this again. Obviously he did 3 days later. I hate this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *