Home  >  Love Couch  >  Broken Hearts

Confronting a Cheater: 15 Things You MUST Do Before, After & During the Talk

Confronting a cheating partner isn’t always easy, especially if they play the victim card. Here’s everything to know when your partner double-crosses you.

Confront a Cheater

Okay, let’s not sugarcoat it. You’ve just discovered your partner is cheating, and right now, you’re a whirlwind of emotions — confusion, betrayal, maybe even rage. Your heart is pounding and your mind is racing with a million questions. The biggest one, though, is how to confront a cheater.

This isn’t just a casual chat, it’s a high-stakes conversation that demands emotional intelligence, assertiveness, and tact. Here’s all you need to know before you embark on your journey of confronting a cheater. [Read: 47 reasons why people cheat & steps to recover & heal from the infidelity]

Before you confront a cheater

We’ve all seen it in movies: The scorned lover dramatically throws evidence across the room, shouting accusations. But let’s be real, this is your life, not a Hollywood script.

Before you find yourself in a confrontation that could very well define the future of your relationship, there are a few crucial steps to consider.

1. Assess your emotional state

First things first, check in with yourself. Your emotions are probably all over the place, but confronting your partner in this state won’t be productive.

Take a step back. Maybe even take a walk or jot down your thoughts. This pause gives your prefrontal cortex—the logical part of your brain—a chance to catch up with your emotional side, making the upcoming conversation more balanced and constructive. [Read: How to get over emotional cheating when your heart is broken]

2. Gather evidence

Before making accusations, make sure you’re not acting solely on a hunch. Maybe you’ve seen some suspicious texts or found questionable photos. Whatever your suspicions are based on, scrutinize the evidence.

Ask yourself if you’re reading too much into things due to your emotional state. Remember, it’s easy to fall into the trap of confirmation bias, where you see what you want to see.

3. Seek advice

While it’s tempting to turn to your closest friends for advice, be cautious. Friends and family have their own life experiences, and their advice might not always be the most objective.

It’s okay to seek their perspectives for a more rounded view, but at the end of the day, remember that this decision is yours to make.

4. Choose the right time and place

Lastly, think carefully about when and where you’ll have this conversation. Opt for a neutral location where both of you can speak freely and without distractions.

Timing matters, too. Choose a moment when you both have time to talk without feeling rushed. A well-timed, well-placed conversation is more likely to lead to a constructive outcome. [Read: 17 confident ways to be more assertive & speak your mind loud and clear]

The confrontation

You’ve done your emotional homework, gathered evidence, and considered various perspectives. Now comes the most challenging part: the confrontation.

Navigating this conversation requires more than just courage, it demands emotional finesse and psychological acumen.

1. “I”-statements and nonviolent communication

You’re emotionally prepped, evidence in hand, advice weighed, and the perfect time and place chosen. Now, let’s talk about how to actually articulate your feelings without launching World War III.

This is where “I”-statements and nonviolent communication come in handy.

Instead of saying, “You made me feel this way,” opt for, “I felt hurt when I discovered the texts.” This subtle shift from “you” to “I” can minimize defensiveness and promote a more constructive dialogue.

In psychology, this is linked to “nonviolent communication,” a technique designed to focus on personal feelings and needs rather than blaming or accusing. The idea is that you’re giving your partner space to respond rather than putting them in a corner. [Read: How to have a difficult conversation without losing your nerve]

2. Sunk cost fallacy

It’s natural to think about all the time and emotional investment you’ve put into the relationship. However, beware of the sunk cost fallacy—an effect that Arkes, H. and Blumer, C. describe as the tendency to continue with a decision because of the time, money, or effort you’ve already committed.

During the confrontation, remember to evaluate the relationship based on its current merits, not what you’ve invested in the past.

If you find yourself thinking, “But we’ve been together for years,” pause and ask whether the relationship is still serving you positively in the present.

3. Feeling sad or lonely doesn’t justify cheating

In confronting your partner, you might hear excuses like, “I was feeling lonely,” or, “I was confused.” While it’s important to listen, it’s also crucial to establish that emotional shortcomings don’t justify the act of cheating.

This aligns with your earlier self-assessment step, where you were urged to regulate your own emotions before taking any action. [Read: Serial cheater – 43 signs & traits, why they cheat so often & what to do next]

4. Reverse the situation

As you navigate this emotionally charged conversation, consider asking your partner how they would feel if roles were reversed. This isn’t to induce guilt but to encourage empathy, a psychological trait that can help create mutual understanding.

Tread lightly here, though, this is a powerful question that can elicit strong reactions, so make sure the timing is right and the atmosphere has remained as non-confrontational as possible.

5. Don’t be manipulated by tears or emotional outbursts

It’s not uncommon for the confronted party to break down emotionally. While these reactions may be genuine, it’s essential to maintain your emotional equilibrium.

In psychology, this kind of emotional display can sometimes be a form of emotional manipulation, designed to shift the focus away from the issue at hand.

Don’t let tears deter you from seeking the truth and resolution you need. [Read: 27 signs of emotional manipulation to know if you’re being used by someone]

6. Avoid using absolutes like “Always” or “Never”

In the heat of the moment, you might be tempted to say things like, “You always lie!” or “You’ve never cared about me!”

However, using absolutes in your statements can exacerbate the tension and create an adversarial atmosphere. It’s a form of cognitive distortion called “all-or-nothing thinking,” and it rarely adds clarity to the situation.

7. Take time to listen

As much as you’re there to express your feelings and seek answers, make sure to also give your partner the space to explain. In doing so, you’re engaging in active listening, a vital skill in conflict resolution.

Sometimes the act of truly hearing the other person can provide you with invaluable insights into your relationship, even when the truth is painful to hear. [Read: 19 ways to be a much better listener in a relationship & read their mind]

8. Be prepared for any outcome

It’s easy to go into the confrontation with a fixed idea of what you want to happen—reconciliation or separation, for instance.

However, being mentally prepared for any outcome makes you more resilient and adaptive, a concept rooted in psychological flexibility.

Remember, the confrontation is as much about discovering the future course of your relationship as it is about addressing the past.

9. Be conscious of body language

Don’t underestimate the power of nonverbal cues. Crossed arms, eye-rolling, or constant interruptions can send a message just as strong as words. [Read: Male body language – 48 subtle signs to instantly read a man’s thoughts]

Being mindful of your body language can support a more open, honest dialogue. In psychology, this is part of what’s often referred to as “paralinguistics,” which can significantly affect interpersonal communication.

Assess their response

You’ve had the courage to confront your cheating partner, but now what? How they respond can be just as telling as the act of cheating itself.

This next part is crucial.

It’s about untangling the web of words and emotions to get to the truth. Let’s equip you with the psychological tools you need to understand defensive mechanisms and gauge sincerity.

1. Defensive mechanisms

Once you’ve laid your cards on the table, you’ll likely encounter a range of defensive mechanisms. These are unconscious psychological strategies that people often use to cope with stress or uncomfortable truths.

Common ones include denial *”I didn’t cheat”, projection *”You’re the one who’s always flirting”*, and rationalization *”It didn’t mean anything, so it’s not a big deal”*. Recognizing these for what they are helps you see through the smoke and mirrors to what’s really going on.

2. Empathic accuracy

Determining the genuineness of your partner’s remorse and willingness to change is a nuanced art. In psychology, this is often referred to as “empathic accuracy”—the ability to accurately perceive another’s emotional state.

Look for congruency between their words and actions, as well as the consistency of their expressions of remorse over time. Remember, genuine change is a sustained effort, not a one-time promise. [Read: Lack of empathy in a relationship – why it matters & how to fix it]

Decide your next steps

You’ve done the tough part—confronting the cheater and gauging their reactions. Now comes another tricky bit: figuring out what you’re going to do about it all. Should you stay? Should you go?

Think about what you have to gain by sticking around and what you could lose.

This is like making a mental pros-and-cons list, which is actually a time-tested psychological method for decision-making. Are the trust and love strong enough to rebuild, or will you always be haunted by doubt?

You’ve put in time and emotions, and maybe even shared a pet or an embarrassing secret or two. This makes it really hard to think about saying goodbye.

It’s tough to break away from what you’re used to, but sometimes it’s necessary for your well-being. [Read: 26 honest steps to let go of someone you love and move on & find peace]

Should you stay or should you go?

Remember, what you choose to do next is yours and yours alone to decide. It might feel like you’re at a crossroads, but you’re also at a starting line.

Whether you stay or go, make sure it’s a choice that respects your worth and honors your emotional well-being.

Yeah, it hurts like a playlist of breakup songs on repeat. But knowing how to confront a cheater equips you with something invaluable: a sense of agency in a situation that’s made you feel powerless.

This isn’t just about them, it’s about you reclaiming your narrative and setting the terms for your emotional well-being.

[Read: Once a cheater always a cheater? 35 truths & must-knows to help you decide]

When learning how to confront a cheater, you need to be ready for them to pull the victim card. With these steps, you’ll be equipped to work through their defensiveness and victimizing acts. What comes after is up to you.

Liked what you just read? Follow us on Instagram Facebook Twitter Pinterest and we promise, we’ll be your lucky charm to a beautiful love life. And while you’re at it, check out MIRL, a cool new social networking app that connects experts and seekers!

Preeti Tewari Serai
Preeti Serai
Preeti, the founder of LovePanky, is an eternal optimist and believer in the beauty of love and life. With an exhaustive experience in love, relationships, and ...