Do Men Have Feelings? Why They Act Like They Don’t Care

do men have feelings

Have you ever wondered why your guy isn’t as excited or as overwhelmed as you are during emotional times? Here’s a glimpse as to why that is.

One of the most common questions I hear from women in relationships is this: why doesn’t he care about me? Why isn’t he showing it?

The answer is easy, ladies. It’s because he doesn’t want to. If a man—no, scratch that—if people wanted to express their feelings, they would do it in a heartbeat. Unfortunately, there are a lot of things that prevent us from communicating.

We might be shy. We might be apprehensive. We might be preoccupied with other things. There are a lot of reasons why people fail to express themselves wholeheartedly, but the thing is, you cannot control how people are programmed.

It’s even more difficult when someone expects us to communicate in a specific way, when it’s not how we were programmed to act—hence the issue about some women wanting their guys to be more open and in tune with their feelings.

Men are a different breed, because they were programmed differently than women. They were told by society not to show feelings and they were told by their fathers not to do what girls do. Even though the line between genders is getting more and more blurry, many men still feel they have to behave a certain way in order to retain their masculinity. [Read: Why men feel so emasculated by the world they’re living in today]

What women really want…

When women complain about their man being too cold or indifferent, they’re not asking them to show emotion. They’re demanding that these men show affection.

There is an obvious difference between the two, yet men still get the reputation of being unfeeling mounds of stone. That’s because affection is, in itself, a show of emotion. If it’s not present, people immediately assume that the person has no feelings, whatsoever.

Just because someone is not willing to show their emotions does not mean that they do not know how to feel. The normal state of the human mind pushes us to show emotions because it aides in our survival. If a person is literally emotionless, they’re either not real, or they’re leaning toward sociopathic behavior.

The truth is, men constantly express their feelings. It’s just not what women expect. Admittedly, more and more people are breaking the barriers and relieving themselves of the status quo, but the fact remains that some women are still wondering why they have to give it up—why can’t men just change, instead?

Why can’t they have romance, while still getting paid the same wage as men? Why can’t they get compassion, while still being hailed as an independent individual? Women want love, but men aren’t as willing to give it. [Read: 25 signs your man really loves you even if he doesn’t say it out loud]

Why are men reluctant to show and express affection?

Let’s go back to the first complaint: why do guys act like they don’t care? Psychologists are just as baffled as you are, which is why they decided to look into why men are reluctant to get in touch with their sensitive side.

Some studies showed that men were wary of women who insisted that they show their true feelings. The reason is that when they finally express themselves, their partners failed to receive the gesture positively. Most women do not know how to handle an emotional man, yet they still insist on openness—and, more often than not, are not ready for the fallout.

Take, for example, when a man finally cries. Usually, this only happens in highly emotional situations. Women ask for men who say, “I love you.” They are rarely ready for a man who says, “I am in pain. Please help me.”

It’s a shock to see someone who you perceive as your protector admitting that they cannot do it. It feels like a threat to your whole being, because if anything happens to you, whether physically or emotionally, your guy is too incapacitated to help you. [Read: 14 things you say or do that emasculates your man and makes him go deeper into a shell]

It’s even more damaging when you don’t acknowledge the effort they made to show you their feelings. Most women end up being either petrified or horrified when it finally dawns on them that men are capable of intense emotions.

This just goes to show that you may be asking for more openness, but not necessarily everything that comes with it. Women say they want their partner to show their feelings, but only certain feelings and in small doses—so little that it might not even be considered opening up at all!

So, whose fault is it?

It’s not anybody’s fault. This is how society evolved. If you can wait a little bit longer, things might change. For now, you’ll have to wait for a man who is not so stuck in the traditional norms that are foisted upon them.

They’re actually experiencing what is called a “double-bind.” Society is pushing them to break out of their shells by being more emotionally expressive, yet when they do, they are perceived as poorly-adjusted.

The problem is that men have been conditioned not to express themselves for so long that the very idea of them showing fear, vulnerability, or sensitivity can be overwhelming for those who witness it. [Read: How a man’s mind works when it comes to love and relationships]

Still, there is a silver lining. Since we’re also talking about how other people perceive men when they show emotion, a positive reaction might encourage them to be more open in the future. If they can express themselves without being judged, there wouldn’t be a need for a show of indifference.

With that in mind, maybe it’s time everybody started accepting the fact that men have just as many feelings as women do. And don’t go blaming hormones for the mismatch; men are carrying a boatload of the most aggression-inducing hormone, testosterone. So, it’s probably a good thing that they don’t PMS like we do.

What can you do to deal with an indifferent partner?

If you’re already dating a guy who’s reluctant to show his emotions, here are your options:

#1 Discuss the need for more openness and communication. It’s not going to be easy, especially if they’re used to being stoic and apathetic, but you should be honest about your needs.

#2 Know when and what questions to ask. Just because your guys isn’t expressive does not mean that he won’t answer your questions about how he is feeling. Let him know your relationship is a safe space.

#3 Don’t pry. If you don’t get the answer you’re expecting, it simply means that your guy doesn’t know what to say or how to explain his feelings to you. Respect his privacy, and move on with your day.

#4 Observe. Even though guys don’t express themselves the usual way, they do so using other outlets:

a. They convert their feelings. For example, instead of being sad, a man might express it as anger or testiness.

b. They put their feelings into other activities. It can be sports, hobbies, or even just going out for some air.

c. Their emotions can manifest as physical pain. Sometimes a headache or a backache can be caused by stresses that guys can’t express verbally. [Read: How to be a good girlfriend – 10 things you HAVE to do]

#5 Accept it. You cannot change a person. You can urge them to make a positive shift in their interactions, but there’s no guarantee that it will work. For now, you can comfort yourself with the fact that your man does feel something. He just doesn’t know how to show it.

#6 If you can’t accept it, do the honorable thing and stop dating someone you can’t connect with. The first thing that you should consider is dating a guy who doesn’t care about what other people think. And when you do, make sure that you’re as open as you want your guy to be. It would be hypocritical of you to demand vulnerability, while remaining hidden, yourself.

[Read: 9 baby steps to get your man to start opening up to you]

Although there are countless jokes and tropes about men and their emotions, many women find themselves genuinely at a loss about men’s feelings. The most common request in a relationship is this: show more emotion. The steps above will help women either overcome their need for more affection, or encourage their men to open up, little by little.

Liked what you just read? Like us on Facebook Twitter Pinterest and we promise, we’ll be your lucky charm to a beautiful love life.

Danielle Anne
Danielle Anne
Those who can’t do, teach. I can neither do nor teach as well as others, but I can try. Aside from being a writer, I am also a physical therapist. My dream is...
Follow Danielle on

Don't Miss this!

Latest in LovePanky

DISCUSSION

6 thoughts on “Do Men Have Feelings? Why They Act Like They Don’t Care”

  1. mark walstone says:

    The way I see it is that two persons who love each other will express their feelings toward one another regardless the gender. Honestly, If your man doesn’t open up to you and share his frustrations, emotions, etc. that means that your relationship might not be that great at all. In our world now where social media is depicted as our real life, it’s easy to label yourself as happy, it’s because that’s what you always post- what you want other people to see.
    So basically, men DO have feelings, you just have to build your relationship first.

    With regards to the author of this article, she gave different ways to deal with your indifferent partner, that is a start when your first building your relationship. You have to build a strong foundation from there.

  2. trolog says:

    “Why can’t they have romance, while still getting paid the same wage as men?” Women do get paid the same wage as men, though when this doesn’t happen it’s strictly because of female life choices, having babies, working less hours, men are more likely to work over time, there are loads of reasons men in some instances get paid more but never is it because they are simply men, this feminism bullshit needs to be stamped out with facts. Also there is an age bracket where women earn more than men but you never hear of that do you? Or how women get much lesser sentences for the same crime as a man, or how we don’t have females in the army draft, or family court systems being incredibly bais towards women, the list goes on and on.

    Simple fact is, men are encouraged by men AND woman not to show emoctions because it’s considered a sign of weakness, no matter what women say even if they believe it or not, they don’t like it when men do show emoctions it’s considered less alpha and less strong.

  3. Melody says:

    I dated a very emotional man, and actually loved it. The only reason we aren’t still together is because he moved out of country for a job, we were both young and had just started our careers, I refused to hold him back and we remain friends. However, since then I’ve dated a few men and just have not been able to connect with them on an emotional level. I struggle with self-esteem issues and can not handle guessing how someone feels. It’s always ended smoothly, no hurt feelings, but it had to end. Like you said, accept it. And if you can’t accept it, end it. I fully agree with this. There’s no need to fight or cast blame, there’s no need to attempt to pry their emotions out. None of that will change it.

  4. Irene says:

    Firstly, I would love to express my utmost delight in finding this article on this wonderful website. I have never known that such talented people existed on our planet Earth.
    Then, I would like to share my similar story. Bae and I were amazing at the beginning, but when we started going out more often or watching movies, I found out that he didn’t have feelings. He was just blank. I was really worried and thousands of questions were swarming in my head, like “How am I going to live with this guy?” and going to the extreme like “Is love enough for our relationship to last?”
    I was doing the fourth mentioned point and after awhile it turned out that he was just super shy and afraid to share his emotions with me. Our love is now stronger than ever and we are happily crying on the movie Up.

  5. Aaron says:

    Yeah, I wish a lot of women would just be more upfront about what it is they want. A direct, open line of communication isn’t such a bad thing. In fact, I prefer that sort of blunt honesty that only comes from being a more introverted character. It would definitely save a lot of blowouts along the way because women seem to be too concerned about how “mean” they’re being perceived as. No, there’s nothing mean about saying what it is you need. It’d be mean of me to ignore it.

  6. John says:

    Men don’t share their feelings with women because women can not be trusted. If her man opens up, the first thing she’ll do is blab all about his private business to her girlfriends. Women are also not honest when they share their feelings. They’ll tell you they love you when they don’t. They’ll tell you they’re fine when they’re not. A woman will use your feelings as a weapon against you. They love drama more than they’ll ever love you. I know all women are not like this, but so many are that it’s not safe for a man to be in a relationship with any woman.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *